Holiday 2017 Comparisons - OPI Coalmates (Love OPI XOXO) - Part 1

From left to right: Moon Dance (Rock This Town, Holiday 2012), Songbird Serenade (My Little Pony, Summer 2017), Life’s Grimm (Happily Never After, Autumn 2017), Black Magic Woman (Star Power Sephora Exclusive, Autumn 2017), Brandy (Night Lights Mystery Box, October 2015), Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous (Swiss, Autumn 2010), Coalmates, After Hours (Dance to the Musique, Autumn 2008), Show Time (In True Fashion, Autumn 2012), Nancy (Black Magic, October 2014), Totally in the Dark (Spring 2013), Trixy, Dot, Ariel, & Marlise (all from Trancing in the Moonlight, October 2017)

Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous is a close cousin to Coalmates if it didn’t have the holo. Brandy and Black Magic Woman are the closest holos but they’re distinctly grayer.

Autumn 2017 Comparisons - Deborah Lippmann Black Magic Woman (Star Power)

From left to right: Storm (Ornate, Holiday 2012), My Private Jet (Originally Night Brights, Summer 2007, Brown version), Black Magic Woman, Ebony (Dark and Stormy Nights, October 2016), Celine (Celestial Cheer, Holiday 2016), Kristjana (This Way to the Soiree, December 2016), Payton (Zenith, Holiday 2013)

I immediately thought of Ebony when I saw Black Magic Woman, and I’m not far off, Ebony’s darker though and the holo is stronger. The version of My Private Jet I have is also pretty close but the base is more brown.

Update with Julep Brandy:

I just got Brandy the other day and it’s really close to Black Magic Woman. The big difference is Brandy has some blue-green glitter in it as well as the holo, but otherwise they’re almost dead-on. The base color is super close.